MYKE ANGELITO MERLAS
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF LAOAG
Abstract
By and large, the
Philippine BPO industry is driven by employment and economic growth through
night shift operations serving North American and European markets. Although
the underlying model has considerable economic value, ethical concerns
regarding employee health, workplace safety, and corporate responsibility
cannot be discounted. This article reviews the issues of occupational health
research, ethics in labor, and relevant Philippine policy frameworks. This
paper is underpinned by the premise that organizations should go beyond basic
legal compliance to proactively ensure the well-being of night shift workers.
The paper identifies policy gaps; highlights best practices; and outlines
recommendations for business leaders, policy makers, and researchers on how to
manage nocturnal labor more ethically and sustainably.
Keywords: Night shift work;
Business Process Outsourcing; ethical challenges; occupational health;
workplace safety; organizational responsibility; Philippines
Introduction
Over the past two decades, the
Philippines positioned itself as a global leader in the business process
outsourcing industry, providing services that range from customer support and
technical assistance to finance and back‑office operations for international
clients. Underpinning this success has been reliance on night shift schedules
designed to align with Western business hours. This indeed has created millions
of jobs and fueled phenomenal economic growth but created ethical concerns
related to employee wellbeing. Night work disrupts one's normal sleeping
pattern, or circadian rhythm, and is consistently linked to adverse health
consequences, increased risk to safety, and social problems.
These issues are more pronounced in
the Philippine setting, as BPO workers are predominantly young, urban, and
economically dependent on wage premiums from nocturnal work. These create
significant ethical concerns in respect of informed consent, long-term health
consequences, and employer liability to protect employee welfare. The
discussion emphasizes balancing economic gains with proactive steps by
organizations and policymakers that adequately protect employee welfare to
ensure the industry maintains a growth path that is both sustainable and
ethically responsible.
The nature and growth of night shift
work in Philippine BPOs
Night shift work in Philippine BPOs
is basically driven by global outsourcing models that leverage time-zone
differences to provide continuous service coverage. International Labour
Organization studies and Philippine labor agencies confirm that the majority of
voice-based BPO services are set during nighttime hours to match the schedules
of Western businesses (Errighi et al., 2016; DOLE, 2020). The competitiveness
of the industry thus rests structurally on night labor.
The ethical questions that this
arrangement raises are those of distributive justice and the allocation of risk.
Where client firms save on costs and continue with seamless operations,
Filipino workers incur physiological and social costs from working against
natural circadian rhythms. Academic literature has warned that financial
incentives, such as night shift differentials, while legally mandated, may not
compensate for cumulative health risks and therefore cannot be an ethically
sufficient justification based on compensation principles (Standing, 2011).
Health implications of night work
Medical and occupational health
studies continue to confirm that night shift working is linked to adverse
physical health conditions, such as cardiovascular disease, metabolic
disorders, gastrointestinal problems, and weakened immune function (Gan et al.,
2015; Wang et al., 2011). The WHO and the International Agency for Research on
Cancer classify night shift work as probably carcinogenic owing to its
disruption of the circadian rhythm (WHO,
2019). Such evidence has been well-established across multiple populations and
are not dependent on country-specific statistics.
Mental and social health effects
are equally well-documented: Night workers have higher rates of sleep
disorders, chronic fatigue, anxiety, and depressive symptoms, all of which lead
to social disconnection because of misalignment with family and community
routines (Booker et
al., 2020). Philippine-based academic studies also underscore the work-life
imbalance among call center employees and highlight ethical concerns regarding
the prolonged exposure of employees to psychosocial stressors without adequate
organizational support (Reyes & Amistad, 2019).
Safety concerns and workplace risks
Fatigue linked to night shift work
increases the risk of committing errors, reduces alertness, and leads to
occupational accidents (Folkard & Tucker, 2003). In the BPO sector, the
risks are compounded by extended periods spent looking at screens and cognitively
demanding tasks during biologically low-alertness periods.
In the Philippine context, safety
hazards of employment extend beyond workplace premises into commuting in
late-night hours when access to safe public transportation is limited. Coverage
and quality vary widely across firms; government and ILO reports note, however,
that some firms offer transportation and security measures (ILO, 2018). Poor
and unequal provisions for safety raise ethical concerns over the differential
protection of workers performing an inherently high-risk schedule.
Organizational responsibilities and
ethical obligations
Ethical frameworks in employment
relations emphasize the duty of care by organizations to avoid foreseeable
harms at the workplace. The International Labour Organization identifies the
responsibility of employers to ascertain occupational risks and implement their
prevention, especially for nonstandard work arrangements such as night shifts
(ILO, 2019).
In the case of Philippine BPOs,
this ethical organizational responsibility requires open disclosure of health
risks during recruitment, periodic health monitoring, access to mental health
support, fatigue management strategies, and investment in safe transportation.
Philippine labor law calls for night shift differentials, but ethical
responsibility means much more than this, placing long-term worker well-being
above short-term productivity gains.
Policy gaps, best practices, and future
directions
Philippine labor laws largely deal
with night work in terms of wage premiums, while less properly integrating
occupational health research into enforceable standards. Gaps in psychosocial
risk management, long-term health surveillance, and fatigue regulation for
night workers have also been recognized in government and academic literature
(DOLE, 2020; ILO, 2019).
These include ergonomic workplace design, evidence-based scheduling, wellness programs, and periodic health assessments that are all considered best practices in several international studies. Therefore, policy development in the future should be done in a way that labor standards are aligned with occupational health evidence, while future research should prioritize longitudinal studies on the cumulative health effects of night shift work among Filipino BPO employees.
Conclusion
The performance of night shift work in Philippine BPOs is embedded in a complex ethics domain regarding health, safety, and organizational responsibility. While the industry has brought economic gains, these must be weighed against the concerns on long-term staff welfare. Ethical business practice dictates that organizations must recognize there is an inherent risk from night work and mitigating this risk involves infrastructures of support. The duty of shaping the BPO sector, which is not only competitive and humane but also ethically founded, lies with the policymakers, employers, and scholars.
References
Booker, L. A., Magee, M.,
Rajaratnam, S. M. W., Sletten, T. L., & Howard, M. E. (2020). Individual
vulnerability to insomnia, excessive sleepiness, and shift work disorder. Sleep,
43(3), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsz280
Department of Labor and Employment
(DOLE). (2020). Working conditions in the business process outsourcing
industry. Government of the Philippines.
Errighi, L., Bodwell, C., &
Khatiwada, S. (2016). Business process outsourcing in the Philippines:
Challenges for decent work. International Labour Organization.
Folkard, S., & Tucker, P.
(2003). Shift work, safety and productivity. Occupational Medicine,
53(2), 95–101. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/kqg047
Gan, Y., Yang, C., Tong, X., et al.
(2015). Shift work and diabetes mellitus: A meta-analysis. Occupational and
Environmental Medicine, 72(1), 72–78.
https://doi.org/10.1136/oemed-2014-102150
International Labour Organization.
(2018). Improving safety and health in night work. ILO.
International Labour Organization.
(2019). Safety and health at the heart of the future of work. ILO.
Reyes, J. P., & Amistad, L. A.
(2019). Work–life balance of night-shift employees in Philippine call centers. Philippine
Journal of Psychology, 52(2), 155–176.
Standing, G. (2011). The
precariat: The new dangerous class. Bloomsbury Academic.
World Health Organization. (2019). Night
shift work and cancer risk. WHO.
https://demolitionnutsgrease.com/q9h97sj5?key=23b279e99ed6a529a30f577cdce2aeb9
No comments:
Post a Comment